|
The God Who Wasn't There | 
 enlarge | Director: Brian Flemming
Actor: Richard Carrier; Richard Dawkins; Alan Dundes; Sam Harris; Robert M. Price
Studio: Beyond Belief Media
Category: DVD
List Price: $24.94
Buy New: $16.31
You Save: $8.63 (35%)
New (4) Used (1) from $15.63
Avg. Customer Rating:  224 reviews
Sales Rank: 1350
Format: Ac-3, Color, Digital Sound, Dolby, Dvd-video, Full Length, Full Screen, Ntsc
Language: English (Original Language)
Rating: NR (Not Rated)
Number Of Items: 1
Running Time: 320
Aspect Ratio: 1.33:1
Shipping Weight (lbs): 0.2
Dimensions (in): 7.1 x 5.4 x 0.6
MPN: 407
UPC: 837101074865
EAN: 0837101074865
ASIN: B000CAPZBC
Theatrical Release Date: June 6, 2005
Publication Date: June 6, 2005
Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days
Shipping: Expedited shipping available
Shipping: International shipping available
Condition: Ships Within 24 Hours - Satisfaction Guaranteed!
|
| Similar Items:
|
| Editorial Reviews:
Description
Bowling for Columbine did it to the gun culture. Super Size Me did it to fast food. Now The God Who Wasn't There does it to religion. Holding modern Christianity up to a bright spotlight, this eye-opening documentary asks the questions few dare to ask. "Did Jesus even exist?" is just the beginning for The God Who Wasn't There. Your guide through the world of Christendom is former fundamentalist Brian Flemming, joined by such luminaries as Jesus Seminar fellow Robert M. Price, author Sam Harris and historian Richard Carrier. In addition to the film, which won the Best Documentary award at the 2005 Grassroots Cinema Film Festival, this feature-packed DVD includes: -Special commentary tracks with Richard Dawkins and Earl Doherty
-Over one hour of compelling additional interview footage
-An in-depth Web-enabled slide show
-Music from the soundtrack
-Bios of all participants This provocative DVD takes off the gloves and gives religion an unprecedented, no-holds-barred examination. So hold on to your faith. It's in for a bumpy ride.
|
| Customer Reviews: Read 219 more reviews...
 Not bad, but a little thin... December 31, 2008
This movie wasn't bad at all, but it felt a little short to me. The questions about the existence of the "historical" Jesus were very intriguing, but I would have liked a bit more depth on the background of the other religious figures whose pre-existing stories so closely followed the tales of the Gospels. Likewise, the interview with his school's director raises some important questions about the ethics of inculcating children with these belief systems, but it doesn't pursue really these questions with any depth. I really feel that an additional 30 minutes could have given a bit of breathing room to these and several other topics.
On the other hand, I can't say that I've seen any other documentaries that even discuss these questions at all, so my complaints will have to be weighed against all the things I did like about the film, which is why I did give it 4 stars.
 A+ Teacher Resource! December 29, 2008
2 out of 2 found this review helpful
As a teacher of world history at an alternative high school in the Four Corners region of the country, I was refreshingly amazed to discover a film that I can use to orient my students to an academically sound timeline of early Christianity. More importantly, the interviews that accompany the body of the film are profoundly valuable classroom resources to introduce students to authentic academic discourse as it takes place among lively and fearless scholars. My students do not have an opportunity to experience anything cut of an even remotely similar fiber. A huge majority of lay conversations in this area are dominated or directed by organized religion's right-wing zealots. Even at the local college, instructors are cautioned against subjecting this community's paper-thin sensitivities to intellectual examination. Because students have simply never been exposed to the breadth of intellectual consideration in which religion is couched, this film represents a rich introduction to the complexities and curiosities that drive science, social science, history, and literature.
Beyond that, it is time we wrested the lectern from the bullies in the pulpit. They are tiresome simpletons, broken records, who shamelessly use fear and terror to constrain the parameters of acceptable discourse. This film inspires me to continue to point out the nakedness of the emperor, the heartless rigidity of intolerance, and the need to educate kids on the broadest scale possible.
Vicki Whitaker
 Smoke, Mirrors, Hype December 23, 2008
4 out of 9 found this review helpful
I viewed this film for the first time and then marched into a debate setting with a young atheist. This was 2005 at the Oriental Theater in Denver, Colorado.
The film gives no solid arguments for its outrageous claim that Jesus never existed. But the cinematic mood is dramatic, however. A man recounts his loss of faith and his journey to justify atheism. You get talking heads of supposed experts giving factoids with no context or substance. You see ignorant Christians sputtering about, giving the impression that this is the best they can do.
Of course, this is a flaming crock. The scholarly world can marshal dozens of credentialed scholars who think the nonexistence of Jesus is absurd. These include the most liberal scholars, such as Crosson, Borg, and others. Further, one can cite evangelical scholars like Blomberg, NT Wright, Ben Witherington, Bock, and others to the effect that the Gospels are historically trustworthy to the point of Jesus' miracles and resurrection from the dead. There are a number of sources outside of the New Testament that testify to Jesus' existence: Josephus, Tacitus, Pliny the Younger, and so on. See the work of Van Voorst, FF Bruce, and Gary Habermas.
The attempt to link Jesus with mystery religions was discredited about fifty years ago. The mystery religions can later and bear little resemblance to the Gospels. See Ed Komoszewski, et al, Reinventing Jesus and Ron Nash, The Gospel and the Greeks.
If you study it out, you find that this film should be called, "The Argument That Wasn't There."
Fun movie, Enjoyable, but short on content December 16, 2008
I finally bought a copy of this movie and I really enjoyed it. Flemming gives an excellent overview of why Christianity's beliefs are founded in nothing more than myths. It takes you through a quick summary of what so many atheists have known for so long. And it's entertaining to watch.
He also gives a pretty startling summary of Mel Gibson's pet movie about Jesus.
However, like any movie of this length, one can only pack so much information into it. I doubt many Christians will stop believing after watching this movie. Rather, I would hope that this movie will open their eyes to issues they might not be aware of, and they will go searching for more answers. In that regard, the movie should be thought of as a brief introduction to the topics laid out.
Jeff Mark
Author, Christian No More
A total waste of time December 7, 2008
1 out of 3 found this review helpful
As someone who makes study of religious debate a hobby, I was very interested to see this film. I was hoping to find a well-thought out, well researched Atheist opinion; what I found was a poorly made argument based on loosely stitched together bits of research. Not once was there a serious historical conversation that supported his views, nor was there a serious conversation that opposed his views. The archetypal mythology was ignored, with the exception of a 5-minute overview of the hero archetype.
Furthermore, I felt that the point of this film was to make Atheists seem correct and intelligent while making Christians seem backwards, foolish, and tyrannical. However, what this film actually did was make the director/narrator come across as a bitter, childish man who blames religion for his problems rather than taking responsibility himself.
As other reviews have said, if you are an Atheist, you will be ashamed of this film, and don't bother watching. If you are a Christian seeking to challenge yourself and grow in your faith, you will be greatly disappointed, and don't bother watching.
|
|
|
Powered by the Force.
|
|
|
Star Wars Gaming Blogs
Fun with Stormtroopers
"Only Imperial stormtroopers are so precise!" Obi-Wan Kenobi, Ep. IV.
"Excuse me, no they're not!" Gidrea Lightsky, SW Galaxies.
Time for me to review - Back to basics
I'm back to reviewing after I had a run in with Section 6 - no hard feelings by the way. Thus I'm moving back to basics and reviewing (which I hope doesn't run into the same issues)
Game Oddities
Well, games are fine. I love them. Beside playing them alot I also want to became a game developer once a day, but thats another story. Games makes fun even games with violent content, even when
Minis scenairo, Old Republic and Clone Wars series
Latest minis scenario plus a couple of comments on The Old Republic and Clone Wars.
Sith Assasin
Another idea for a game! (Basically Assassins Creed mixed with SW)
Could The Old Republic & Kotor 3 Exist Together?
I tackle the very interesting question and want to hear from readers about it!
ShaunCon XXIV now approaching
I'll be at ShaunCon XXIV this weekend, along with a few other Star Wars RPG freelancers.
Catching up...
Catching up on a few updates - more Clone Wars minis previews, more KOTOR Campaign Guide web enhancements.
KOTOR III Confirmed!
I hope this isn't old news...
Star Wars Battlefront II
I started writing the blog on the 1st so technically I started it while it was still the 3rd anniversary of the game. 
Star Wars: Massively made and Multiplayer Mayhem
Some thoughts on The Old Republic after a week of decompression.
3 CHEERS FOR SHAAK Ti
Shaak it is the most favoritable jedi between qui-gon jinn and Yoda, well in my opinion. Shaak ti has brought us so many things, and techincally started the rebellion. Shaak ti's death was neccesary for Ghent Starkiller to influence the rebellion. Shaak
|
|
|
|
|
| |
)
